Investigating the Differences Between Optical and Electrochemical Dissolved Oxygen Meters

Investigating the Differences Between Optical and Electrochemical Dissolved Oxygen Meters

Measuring dissolved oxygen (DO) in water is vital for many applications, including monitoring aquatic ecosystems, industrial wastewater treatment, and aquaculture. DO meters are devices designed to measure oxygen saturation in a liquid or gas. There are different types of DO meters available in the market, including optical and electrochemical DO meters. Although both types of meters measure dissolved oxygen, they work on different principles. In this article, we will explore the differences between optical and electrochemical DO meters.

Optical DO Meters

Optical DO meters measure DO by observing how light behaves in water. When light enters the water, it gets absorbed and scattered by water molecules, dissolved particles, and dissolved gases. The amount of oxygen in the water affects how much light gets absorbed or scattered. Optical DO meters use this principle to measure dissolved oxygen in water. The meter emits light of a specific wavelength into the water, and a sensor measures the light that is transmitted through the water. The meter then calculates DO concentration based on the amount of light that gets absorbed or scattered by the oxygen in the water. Optical DO meters are relatively easy to use and do not require calibration or replacement of parts such as sensors or electrodes. They are ideal for applications that require frequent measurements or continuous monitoring.

Electrochemical DO Meters

Electrochemical DO meters, on the other hand, measure DO by detecting the electrical current generated when oxygen is reduced at a cathode electrode. The meter consists of a probe with a sensing electrode and a reference electrode. The sensing electrode is coated with a material that reacts with oxygen when it comes in contact with water. The reaction generates electrons, which flow through an external circuit, creating an electrical current that the meter measures. The current is proportional to the amount of oxygen in the water. Electrochemical DO meters require calibration and replacement of parts such as sensor membranes and electrolytes periodically. They are suitable for applications that require high accuracy but are not intended for continuous or frequent measurements.

Differences Between Optical and Electrochemical DO Meters

Measurement Principle

The primary difference between optical and electrochemical DO meters is their measurement principle. Optical DO meters measure DO by observing how light behaves in water, while electrochemical DO meters measure DO by detecting the electrical current generated when oxygen is reduced at a cathode electrode.

Accuracy

Both optical and electrochemical DO meters are accurate for DO measurements. However, electrochemical DO meters are usually more accurate than optical DO meters, especially at low DO concentrations.

Calibration

Optical DO meters do not require calibration, as they do not have sensors or electrodes that need replacement. Electrochemical DO meters require calibration and replacement of parts such as sensor membranes and electrolytes periodically, which can be time-consuming and expensive.

Maintenance

Optical DO meters are less maintenance-intensive than electrochemical DO meters, as they do not require calibration or replacement of parts such as sensors or electrodes.

Cost

The cost of an optical DO meter is generally lower than that of an electrochemical DO meter. An optical DO meter is a more cost-effective option for applications that require frequent measurements or continuous monitoring.

Conclusion

Both optical and electrochemical DO meters have their advantages and disadvantages, and the type of DO meter used depends on the application. Optical DO meters are easy to use and cost-effective for frequent or continuous measurements, while electrochemical DO meters provide high accuracy and are suitable for applications that require high precision. Understanding the differences between the two types of DO meters is essential in selecting the appropriate DO meter for different applications.

Shanghai Boqu Instrument Co., Ltd. has created its reputation on a commitment to manufacturing high-quality products and services while satisfy the needs of customers.
Serving others for customers a better life with water analyzer for employees respect and opportunity.
Shanghai Boqu Instrument Co., Ltd. will give you a suitable price for purchasing water analyzer.